William Shatner’s Well-Intentioned Actions Led to Challenges for Star Trek Director


The set of the original Star Trek series encountered some tension during its second season due to William Shatner’s actions that almost caused production disruptions. Shatner, known for his portrayal of Captain James T. Kirk, led the cast in a minor mutiny that involved rearranging the set for rehearsal purposes, which did not sit well with director Joseph Pevney.

The issue arose when Shatner and the cast requested a table for rehearsal, seeking to imprint their own interpretations onto their respective Star Trek characters. However, Pevney took exception to Shatner’s handling of the situation. He viewed Shatner’s actions, such as rearranging the set for rehearsals, as problematic within the tight television production schedule, requiring constant script changes and approvals.

The conflict escalated until Star Trek creator Gene Roddenberry intervened and proposed a compromise, recognizing the actors’ contributions to their characters. While this compromise appeased the actors, it frustrated Pevney, who believed the script should serve as the director’s guiding bible on set.


Pevney’s traditional approach clashed with the actors’ desire to refine their characters, particularly Shatner and Leonard Nimoy (who played Spock), who expressed similar concerns. Despite the turmoil it caused on set, associate producer Robert H. Justman acknowledged that Shatner and Nimoy aimed to improve the show and make their characters more believable, even if it created challenges for the production team.

Justman admitted that accommodating the actors’ requests, albeit late in the production process, was an effort to enhance the show’s quality, even though it made their lives “hell” due to the time constraints.

In retrospect, while Shatner’s actions may have caused disruptions, the actors’ commitment to refining their characters ultimately contributed to the show’s enduring legacy as one of the best TV series, indicating their dedication to enhancing the quality of Star Trek, even at the expense of production challenges.