The mention of “The Grinch” immediately conjures Jim Carrey’s wide grin and that distinctively fluffy, green sideburns. Yet, the revelation that Jack Nicholson was nearly cast as the curmudgeonly creature years prior to Carrey’s portrayal sparks a tantalizing “what if” scenario.
While Jim Carrey undoubtedly proved to be a perfect fit for the role of Whoville’s tormentor, capturing the Grinch’s unhinged energy with uncanny ease and infusing the character with his comedic brilliance, the idea of a CGI Grinch inspired by Jack Nicholson remains an intriguing concept worth exploring.
Renowned artist Berkeley Breathed delved into creating concept art for a Grinch/Nicholson hybrid, envisioning a CG-animated romp with Nicholson taking on the lead role. Although the Christmas movie didn’t materialize, Breathed’s artwork vividly portrayed the Grinch slumped in a desolate Who house, perfectly capturing Nicholson’s distinctive eyebrows in cartoon form, and capturing iconic moments like Grinchy standing atop Mount Crumpet reveling in his Christmas-time antics. His rendition paid homage to the classic 1966 animated movie while offering a surrealistic twist on Seuss’ iconic festive character.
Despite earning the approval of significant figures, including Dr. Seuss’s widow Audrey Geisel, the project fell short. Breathed expressed disappointment, revealing that Geisel favored Ron Howard’s vision, leading to Universal’s option money taking precedence. Ultimately, the Nicholson-led film didn’t come to fruition, paving the way for Carrey’s memorable portrayal, a rendition that fans now cherish.
Carrey and Howard’s rendition of “How the Grinch Stole Christmas” impeccably captured the essence of the story. The film, laugh-out-loud funny and incredibly creative in its portrayal of Whoville, showcased Carrey’s Grinch journeying from a terrifying figure to an endearing hero. Undoubtedly, it stands as one of the best Christmas movies, weaving its magic into our festive celebrations and leaving an indelible mark on our holiday movie traditions.