Gene Siskel’s Disbelief Over Roger Ebert’s Favorite ‘Home Alone’ Movie


It’s intriguing to delve into the contrasting perspectives between Roger Ebert and Gene Siskel regarding the “Home Alone” film franchise. Their differing opinions, especially concerning “Home Alone 3,” revealed their distinct viewpoints on the sequels and their preferences in storytelling and character portrayal.

Ebert’s stance on “Home Alone 3” being better than its predecessors was indeed surprising to Siskel, especially regarding Ebert’s comment on its reduced violence. Siskel pointed out the contradictory nature of this claim by highlighting the increased violence compared to the original film. Moreover, Ebert’s assertion that the third installment was superior because it provided a sense of empowerment for kids was also contested by Siskel. He highlighted how the theme of children gaining power over adults was inherent in the first movie and carried over into the sequels.

The enduring appeal of the original “Home Alone” movies, predominantly due to Macaulay Culkin’s presence, emphasizes the challenge faced by subsequent installments in replicating that success. Ebert’s hypothetical opinion on “Home Sweet Home Alone,” the sixth film in the series, might have continued to laud the film, considering its merits. However, Siskel might have reiterated that the essence of the series was perfected in the initial movies and that subsequent attempts may have diluted the original premise.


Their differing views on the franchise underscore the subjective nature of film criticism and the varied perspectives critics bring to their evaluations. While Ebert might have seen merit in the later films, Siskel’s reservations would have likely revolved around the inability of subsequent installments to capture the essence that made the first two movies iconic.

Ultimately, the divergent opinions between Ebert and Siskel added an engaging dynamic to their reviews, reflecting the multifaceted nature of film critique and the subjective interpretation of cinematic storytelling.